Saturday, November 27, 2010

Wesch - Thinking Differently, Doing Differently

OK, there are several things going on here; basically a critique of the two most famous Wesch videos, The Machine is Using Us and a Vision of Students Today, seen by at least 5 million people and how does this fit into the future of education.

Its really hard to look at these videos and find anything wrong at all with them other than nitpicking at the fact that they are not professionally done. That would move the conversation right around the barn to completely avoid the point. The point is participation, getting your students to do something other than sit passively as your captive audience while listening to yet another lecture. They look like they are listening however that electronic glow is filling their eyes and they are out there somewhere in cyberspace, lost.

Is peer production the future of education...who knows. I know that doing something and creating excitement will certainly be far more interesting than sitting and listening any day. All this has been said before and by more articulate people than I.

Of the two videos my personal favorite is The Machine is Us/ing Us. As I am a fan of McLuhan and hypertext in general I was blown away the first time I ever saw this video. Though it immediately reminded me of a paper I had read years ago:

Mejias, U. (2004, September 1). Online discourse: past, present and future. Presented at the 16th Annual Instructional Technology Institute Conference. Utah State University, Logan, Utah.

Good thing I tend to save random items cause I can not find this online anywhere, Ulises if you see this please add this back to your site. The first line of the paper is "Text is firmly established as the preferred online discourse medium." Of course this is not really Wesch's point in The Machine. His point seems to be the machine is us using the machine or as Kevin Kelly puts is, "We are the web."

I really have gotten a lot from both the videos and the seminar, seriously I got like 4 pages of notes. Yes, I do notes the old fashioned way.

Some resources to consider:
http://blog.ulisesmejias.com/
the ‘Visitors & Residents’ principle
http://digitalcampus.tv/
ZaidLearn Tools Post
100 Incredible Lectures from the World’s Top Scientists
The Best TED Talks To Make Use Of Social Media

1 comment:

  1. I like that Richard: "move the conversation right around the barn to completely avoid the point" - too funny. I tend to remind myself and my students that text is still king. I love videos and pictures, but the real breakthru was the hypertext part of things- the ability to no longer be constrained by the linear nature of books and other documents. Wikipedia still supports this theory of mine- I'll take wikipedia over youtube and flickr (for now)... wonder when that'll change?

    ReplyDelete