Tuesday, December 7, 2010

Theory of Bouncing Lights

If you haven't seen A Private Universe and you are involved in education then drop what you are doing go directly to the bottom of this post and watch it. However do so only after considering the two following questions and writing down your answers, do not cheat work from memory.

What causes the seasons/temperature differences on earth thru the year?

What causes the phases of the moon (from new moon to full moon)?

I got one right (at least half right that is I added something wrong) and one wrong. Perplexed. Me too. I thought I knew. I thought I had a handle on the simple stuff. I was wrong. I was no better in 2010 than the Harvard grads and instructors were in 1987 when this thing was produced. 21 of 23 of Harvard students and professors got the two questions wrong. That's right 21 of 23 got it wrong.

There are three important things going on here and none of this has to do with money or how good your school is. First, adults and students have assumptions. Second, textbooks are partially at fault or more directly the instructional design in some textbooks is poor. Third, simple awareness.

OK, assumptions we all have them. My dad always told me and yours did to that, "assume makes an ass of u and me." Of course we all have them which means your student have them. The basic take away here is that assumptions must be challenged from the instructor in order for the student to learn.

Poor instructional design. A Private Universe come directly out and says that the perspective drawings of these concepts causes misconceptions. This is just poor instructional design. The amount of money that goes into a textbook and the result is bad instructional design this just seems wrong, almost criminal. What is the excuse? Who knows however the problem is a simple one to solve. Better pictures and instructor diligence.

Awareness. An awareness of what your private theories are at the beginning of learning a new concept will help learning a new concept better. Before learning something think about what you think you know and write it down then receive the instruction. It can be humbling to realize that you can be wrong about simple things. This is a step I will try and practice in the future.

What this all means for education is students are being faced with new concepts while doing battle with their pre-conceptions. Its in this battle where misconceptions occur. In order to reverse this it is important for the instructor to challenge thier own assumptions about what the students know.

A Private Universe.

No comments:

Post a Comment