Saturday, December 4, 2010

Social Bookmarking

OK I was a bit worried when I found out that Xmarks was calling it quits, of course within a reasonable amount of time I also found out that Xmarks was purchased by Last Pass. This caused me to look my old delicious account and get reacquainted with the service. Well delicious hasn't really changed much from what I remember though it the UI has gotten better overtime. Now things are so much easier since I am using a Chrome extension which helps with adding bookmarks. I am now a bookmarking fool of course I will be cleaning up my Xmarks account and figuring out a way to import those in Delicious. Now if only there was a way to sync between the two services.

Wiki-universe experience

I recently took a bit of a turn in the wiki-universe by editing in Wikipedia, Wikiversity and the Wiktionary. While I have used these resources in the past I had never edited before. So this was my turn on the wheel. Overall I enjoyed the experience as there is a kind of illicit thrill to editing some-else's document without their permission. I did not have much trouble getting into the wiki markup as I had some experience with it in the past. I found that I was drawn to Wikipedia experience out of the three however I will be exploring the Wikiversity more in the future. One reason I did not the Wiktionary is that this resource seems to appeal more to english geeks in general.

One amazing thing about the Wikimedia Foundation is that when you register on one site its very easy to link one account to another. In my case I linked Wikipedia to both Wiktionary and Wikiversity. The fact that you can do is amazing since even with Open ID I have had issues loging onto accounts using existing accounts. One issue with this however is the user page that I created on Wikipedia is not easily linked from the other accounts. This lead me to create an user page on Wiktionary which ended up getting flagged as a vanity page. It should not be a problem to add a way to link an existing user page from another Wikimedia service. This really is a small complaint as my overall user experience was consistent and good.

Thursday, December 2, 2010

Kevin Kelly, the Technium and the 7th Kingdom

Wow! Kevin Kelly is blowing up the web right now with his new book, What Technology Wants. Mr. Kelly has popped up a lot for me over the years, as I am a fan of Wired magazine which he co-founded in 1993. He takes a much broader view of technology than the vast majority of people. He basically looks at technology as if it were alive or a living ecosystem. Part of the reasoning for this is that we, as humans, do not have a good grasp of what technology is or how it should be defined. He references lots historical examples like; the term technology was not coined until Johann Beckmann did sometime before the 1800s yet the word was not used in English until 1829.

There are some key ideas that you might want to absorb before watching the embedded videos.

The Technium: The whole ecosystem of technology. Technology is defined as being "anything useful that a mind makes, any mind." The Technium also displays emergent behaviors not present in any individual component and also has a bias independent of humans.

The 7th Kingdom: Refers to the Technium itself as an addition to the other Six Kingdoms of Life (ie. Animalia, Plantae, Fungi, Protista, Archaea and Bacteria) However the Technium has properties which are similar to biology like evolution, complexity, diversity and energy density. The 7th Kingdom also displays a major difference from the biological kingdoms; Technology does not go extinct.

Extropy: Not the exact opposite of entropy think of the term to mean a self-organizing system like a star forming.

KK can explain this better than I can so I will let him.

Penny Thoughts on The Technium


Kevin Kelly TEDTalks 2005


Here is an overview of what the books main ideas:
* Technology is the most powerful force on the planet.
* Technology is an extension of evolutionary life, best thought of as the 7th kingdom of life.
* Humanity is our first technology; We are tools.
* Technology is selfish; as a system it exhibits its own urges and tendencies.
* Technologies cannot be banned, and none go extinct.
* The progression of technologies is inevitable.
* Because technologies are inevitable we can prepare to optimize their benefits.
* Technology is not neutral but serves as an overwhelming positive force in human culture.
* We have a moral obligation to increase technology because it increases opportunities.
* The origins of technology lie in the Big Bang.
* Technology preceded humans and will continue beyond us.
* Among the things technology wants are increased diversity, complexity, and beauty.
* Technology may be as much a reflection of the divine as nature is.
* Technology is an infinite game, a grand story we can align ourselves with for greater meaning.

I can't say that I am totally drinking the Kool-Aid here however as a thinker Kevin Kelly has give us a lot of good ideas over the years. Even though I haven't read the book for myself I have read, watched and listened to many articles and interviews over the last several days. I can say that his ideas are interesting though the questions he presents are by far ever more interesting.

Resources:

The Technium
Technoplilia
THE TECHNIUM AND THE 7TH KINGDOM OF LIFE
The Buddhist Geeks
The Agony Column

A brief mention in this introduction for the aforementioned Technoplilia. The introduction contains links to several articles which are now on my reading list.

Introduction to The Best Technology Writing 2010

Eco and Media Literacy

In a recent interview with Umberto Eco, who penned In the Name of the Rose which was turned into a movie starring Sean Connery, seems to be coming out in favor of media literacy. Check out the brief excerpt below:

SPIEGEL: But you also said that lists can establish order. So, do both order and anarchy apply? That would make the Internet, and the lists that the search engine Google creates, prefect for you.

Eco: Yes, in the case of Google, both things do converge. Google makes a list, but the minute I look at my Google-generated list, it has already changed. These lists can be dangerous -- not for old people like me, who have acquired their knowledge in another way, but for young people, for whom Google is a tragedy. Schools ought to teach the high art of how to be discriminating.

SPIEGEL: Are you saying that teachers should instruct students on the difference between good and bad? If so, how should they do that?

Eco: Education should return to the way it was in the workshops of the Renaissance. There, the masters may not necessarily have been able to explain to their students why a painting was good in theoretical terms, but they did so in more practical ways. Look, this is what your finger can look like, and this is what it has to look like. Look, this is a good mixing of colors. The same approach should be used in school when dealing with the Internet. The teacher should say: "Choose any old subject, whether it be German history or the life of ants. Search 25 different Web pages and, by comparing them, try to figure out which one has good information." If 10 pages describe the same thing, it can be a sign that the information printed there is correct. But it can also be a sign that some sites merely copied the others' mistakes.

Though it seems, to me, like the statement is a bit of a slam against the internet in general. I like that he says that schools should be teaching how to be discriminating, the difference between good and bad information. So, media literacy it's a good idea whose time has long since come.

Reference:

http://www.spiegel.de/international/zeitgeist/0,1518,659577,00.html

Saturday, November 27, 2010

Crowdsourcing

Crowd-sourcing is a bit like outsourcing except that you don't have to part to get the work done and there are more people involved. Also so far I haven't heard about crowd-sourcing costing anyone their job. Though after reading the wiki article I see that it has cost several companies. However I wonder if this has more to do with how the crowd-sourcing was implemented than with the effort itself. Games seem to be a big motivator in this area.

As describe in the video, linked below, this is the case. The presenter talks about CAPTCHAs first off as that is the type of human computation that is very familiar to people. Of course he moves on to talk about the game he invented, The ESP Game, and how he is using it to help label images.

This of course ties in neatly which the Google Image Labeler we were asked to experiment with for our course. I only scored a 1270 with my partner in three rounds and then I quit. The mains reasons I didn't keep going were lack of interest, spelling (I am not a great speller) and keyboarding skills (it takes forever for me to type a blog post).

While I was not interested in this game I was reminded about several NASA efforts in this area which were far more interesting to me. I seem to remember that NASA, because of the large amount of data coming from the Hubble Telescope, decided to train people to look for specific stellar phenomena. The training only took an hour. Of course I can not give you any facts about how quickly the data was searched through or how many people participated as I have yet to find the website in order to verify if this is true or not. Of course I could just be imagining it all. Or it could be a devious trick in order to get you all to do my dirty work. You decide.

Crowdsourcing
Google Image Labeler
Human Computation

Wesch - Thinking Differently, Doing Differently

OK, there are several things going on here; basically a critique of the two most famous Wesch videos, The Machine is Using Us and a Vision of Students Today, seen by at least 5 million people and how does this fit into the future of education.

Its really hard to look at these videos and find anything wrong at all with them other than nitpicking at the fact that they are not professionally done. That would move the conversation right around the barn to completely avoid the point. The point is participation, getting your students to do something other than sit passively as your captive audience while listening to yet another lecture. They look like they are listening however that electronic glow is filling their eyes and they are out there somewhere in cyberspace, lost.

Is peer production the future of education...who knows. I know that doing something and creating excitement will certainly be far more interesting than sitting and listening any day. All this has been said before and by more articulate people than I.

Of the two videos my personal favorite is The Machine is Us/ing Us. As I am a fan of McLuhan and hypertext in general I was blown away the first time I ever saw this video. Though it immediately reminded me of a paper I had read years ago:

Mejias, U. (2004, September 1). Online discourse: past, present and future. Presented at the 16th Annual Instructional Technology Institute Conference. Utah State University, Logan, Utah.

Good thing I tend to save random items cause I can not find this online anywhere, Ulises if you see this please add this back to your site. The first line of the paper is "Text is firmly established as the preferred online discourse medium." Of course this is not really Wesch's point in The Machine. His point seems to be the machine is us using the machine or as Kevin Kelly puts is, "We are the web."

I really have gotten a lot from both the videos and the seminar, seriously I got like 4 pages of notes. Yes, I do notes the old fashioned way.

Some resources to consider:
http://blog.ulisesmejias.com/
the ‘Visitors & Residents’ principle
http://digitalcampus.tv/
ZaidLearn Tools Post
100 Incredible Lectures from the World’s Top Scientists
The Best TED Talks To Make Use Of Social Media